⚖️ Islamic Jurisprudence (Fiqh)
Common rulings across the four major madhabs
What are the five daily prayers and when are they prayed?
The five daily prayers (Salah) are obligatory (fard) on every Muslim who has reached puberty and is sane. They are Fajr (dawn), Dhuhr (midday), Asr (afternoon), Maghrib (sunset), and Isha (night). Missing a prayer without a valid excuse is a major sin. Each has a specific time window during which it must be performed.
Comparative School Breakdown
Agrees on the obligation of five prayers. Has specific time calculations that slightly differ for Asr (uses shadow length of 2x the object vs. 1x used by others).
Agrees. Encourages praying in congregation. Considers it recommended to delay Isha until about a third of the night has passed.
Agrees. Emphasizes the importance of facing the exact direction of the Kaaba (precise qibla).
Agrees. Highly emphasizes congregation prayer; considers abandoning prayer without excuse to be an act of disbelief.
Is it permissible to combine prayers while travelling?
Yes, a traveller may combine Dhuhr with Asr (prayed together) and Maghrib with Isha (prayed together). The minimum travel distance that allows this is approximately 80–90 km (48 miles) according to the majority. The traveller may also shorten the 4-rakah prayers (Dhuhr, Asr, Isha) to 2 rakahs.
Comparative School Breakdown
Allows combining only at Arafat and Muzdalifah (during Hajj). Outside of Hajj, combining is not allowed; shortening (qasr) is allowed.
Allows combining during travel. The traveller has the choice to combine or pray at the normal times.
Allows combining during travel. The journey must be at least 81 km and the person must not intend to stay for more than 4 days.
Allows combining during travel and also in cases of rain, illness, or other hardship.
What invalidates wudu (ablution)?
The acts that nullify wudu include: passing wind, urine or stool, losing consciousness (sleep, fainting), eating camel meat (according to Hanbali), touching the private parts directly (majority opinion), and sexual fluids. Once wudu is broken, one must perform it again before praying, touching the Quran, or performing tawaf.
Comparative School Breakdown
Includes flowing blood or pus from the body and vomiting a mouthful as nullifiers.
Does not consider vomiting or blood as nullifiers. Touching a non-mahram woman of the opposite sex with desire nullifies wudu.
Touching a non-mahram member of the opposite sex (even without desire) nullifies wudu.
Eating camel meat invalidates wudu. Also includes washing a deceased person.
What are the rulings on fasting in Ramadan?
Fasting in Ramadan is obligatory for every adult Muslim who is sane, healthy, and not travelling. One must abstain from food, drink, and sexual relations from dawn (Fajr) to sunset (Maghrib). Those who are ill, travelling, pregnant, breastfeeding, elderly, or menstruating are exempt and must make up missed fasts later (except the elderly who may pay fidya instead).
Comparative School Breakdown
Intention must be made before Fajr for obligatory fasts. Unintentional eating or drinking does not break the fast.
Agrees broadly. Considers vomiting intentionally to break the fast but not unintentional vomiting.
Agrees. Intention can be made any time during the night before Fajr.
Agrees. Emphasizes that the intention must be specific (niyyah for Ramadan, not just any fast).
Who is required to pay Zakat and how much?
Zakat is obligatory on every Muslim who owns wealth above the nisab (minimum threshold) for one lunar year. The nisab is equivalent to 87.48g of gold or 612.36g of silver. The standard Zakat rate is 2.5% on gold, silver, and cash savings. Zakat is distributed to eight categories of recipients mentioned in Quran 9:60.
Comparative School Breakdown
Uses the silver nisab as the primary standard, which is generally lower than gold. This is considered more beneficial for the poor.
Agrees on 2.5% but has specific rulings on agricultural produce and livestock.
Gold and silver each have their own separate nisab. If one holds only gold, the gold nisab applies.
Agrees with the standard ruling. Emphasizes that zakat on business goods is also obligatory.
What are the conditions for a valid Islamic marriage?
For a valid Islamic marriage (nikah), the following are required: offer and acceptance (ijab and qabul), the presence of a guardian (wali) for the bride, at least two Muslim witnesses, and a mahr (dowry) paid or promised to the bride. The marriage contract should be publicly announced. Marriage to certain categories of women is permanently or temporarily prohibited.
Comparative School Breakdown
A woman can contract her own marriage without a wali if she is of sound mind and mature age.
The wali is a pillar of the marriage contract — the marriage is invalid without him.
The wali is required. A virgin cannot be married without her wali's consent.
The wali is required. Agrees broadly with the Shafi'i position.
What foods and drinks are forbidden (haram) in Islam?
Forbidden foods include pork and its by-products, blood, animals that died without being properly slaughtered (mayta), animals slaughtered in the name of other than Allah, carnivorous animals with fangs, birds of prey, and intoxicants (alcohol). Halal meat requires the animal to be slaughtered by a Muslim, Christian, or Jew while pronouncing the name of Allah.
Comparative School Breakdown
Considers all aquatic animals except fish to be impermissible. Insects are not permissible.
All sea creatures are permissible (including shrimp, lobster). Considers most insects impermissible.
All sea creatures are permissible. Locusts are permissible.
Generally permits all sea creatures. Agrees locusts are permitted.
Is intention required for acts of worship?
Intention (niyyah) is a prerequisite for all acts of worship in Islam. 'Actions are judged by intentions' (Hadith). The intention must be in the heart — speaking it aloud is a matter of scholarly difference. The intention distinguishes acts of worship from habit (e.g., fasting as an act of worship vs. simply not eating).
Comparative School Breakdown
Verbal intention is recommended (mustahabb) for prayer and Hajj. For fasting, the intention must be made before Fajr.
Verbal intention is an innovation (bid'ah) — the intention is in the heart alone.
Verbal intention is recommended (mustahabb) to help align the heart and tongue.
Verbal intention is not recommended. The intention is strictly in the heart.
Is Friday prayer (Jumu'ah) obligatory?
Friday prayer (Salat al-Jumu'ah) is a collective obligation (fard ayn) on every adult free Muslim male who is resident (not travelling). It replaces the Dhuhr prayer on Fridays. It consists of two rakahs and is preceded by two khutbahs (sermons). Missing three consecutive Fridays without a valid excuse is described in hadith as a cause of the heart being sealed.
Comparative School Breakdown
Requires a minimum number of people (varies: 3 to 40 according to different opinions). Women are exempt but may attend.
Women are generally exempt. Requires a town or settlement for validity.
Requires a minimum of 40 permanent residents. Travellers are exempt.
Requires 40 free adult male residents. Travellers and women are exempt.
Is bank interest (riba) forbidden in Islam?
Riba (usury/interest) is strictly prohibited in Islam. The Quran warns that those who deal in riba are in a state of war with Allah and His Messenger. This includes all forms of predetermined interest on loans. Islamic finance alternatives include murabaha (cost-plus sale), musharakah (partnership), and sukuk (Islamic bonds). All four schools agree on the prohibition of riba.
Comparative School Breakdown
Riba applies to six items mentioned in hadith: gold, silver, wheat, barley, dates, salt. Extends by analogy to all items sold by weight or measure.
Extends prohibition to all edibles and monetary items. Specifically addresses riba in currency exchange.
Agrees riba applies to gold, silver, and all edible items sold by weight or volume.
Broadly prohibits riba. Considers it one of the major sins.
What are the five daily prayers and when are they prayed?
The five daily prayers (Salah) are obligatory (fard) on every Muslim who has reached puberty and is sane. They are Fajr (dawn), Dhuhr (midday), Asr (afternoon), Maghrib (sunset), and Isha (night). Missing a prayer without a valid excuse is a major sin. Each has a specific time window during which it must be performed.
Comparative School Breakdown
Agrees on the obligation of five prayers. Has specific time calculations that slightly differ for Asr (uses shadow length of 2x the object vs. 1x used by others).
Agrees. Encourages praying in congregation. Considers it recommended to delay Isha until about a third of the night has passed.
Agrees. Emphasizes the importance of facing the exact direction of the Kaaba (precise qibla).
Agrees. Highly emphasizes congregation prayer; considers abandoning prayer without excuse to be an act of disbelief.
Is it permissible to combine prayers while travelling?
Yes, a traveller may combine Dhuhr with Asr (prayed together) and Maghrib with Isha (prayed together). The minimum travel distance that allows this is approximately 80–90 km (48 miles) according to the majority. The traveller may also shorten the 4-rakah prayers (Dhuhr, Asr, Isha) to 2 rakahs.
Comparative School Breakdown
Allows combining only at Arafat and Muzdalifah (during Hajj). Outside of Hajj, combining is not allowed; shortening (qasr) is allowed.
Allows combining during travel. The traveller has the choice to combine or pray at the normal times.
Allows combining during travel. The journey must be at least 81 km and the person must not intend to stay for more than 4 days.
Allows combining during travel and also in cases of rain, illness, or other hardship.
What invalidates wudu (ablution)?
The acts that nullify wudu include: passing wind, urine or stool, losing consciousness (sleep, fainting), eating camel meat (according to Hanbali), touching the private parts directly (majority opinion), and sexual fluids. Once wudu is broken, one must perform it again before praying, touching the Quran, or performing tawaf.
Comparative School Breakdown
Includes flowing blood or pus from the body and vomiting a mouthful as nullifiers.
Does not consider vomiting or blood as nullifiers. Touching a non-mahram woman of the opposite sex with desire nullifies wudu.
Touching a non-mahram member of the opposite sex (even without desire) nullifies wudu.
Eating camel meat invalidates wudu. Also includes washing a deceased person.
What are the rulings on fasting in Ramadan?
Fasting in Ramadan is obligatory for every adult Muslim who is sane, healthy, and not travelling. One must abstain from food, drink, and sexual relations from dawn (Fajr) to sunset (Maghrib). Those who are ill, travelling, pregnant, breastfeeding, elderly, or menstruating are exempt and must make up missed fasts later (except the elderly who may pay fidya instead).
Comparative School Breakdown
Intention must be made before Fajr for obligatory fasts. Unintentional eating or drinking does not break the fast.
Agrees broadly. Considers vomiting intentionally to break the fast but not unintentional vomiting.
Agrees. Intention can be made any time during the night before Fajr.
Agrees. Emphasizes that the intention must be specific (niyyah for Ramadan, not just any fast).
Who is required to pay Zakat and how much?
Zakat is obligatory on every Muslim who owns wealth above the nisab (minimum threshold) for one lunar year. The nisab is equivalent to 87.48g of gold or 612.36g of silver. The standard Zakat rate is 2.5% on gold, silver, and cash savings. Zakat is distributed to eight categories of recipients mentioned in Quran 9:60.
Comparative School Breakdown
Uses the silver nisab as the primary standard, which is generally lower than gold. This is considered more beneficial for the poor.
Agrees on 2.5% but has specific rulings on agricultural produce and livestock.
Gold and silver each have their own separate nisab. If one holds only gold, the gold nisab applies.
Agrees with the standard ruling. Emphasizes that zakat on business goods is also obligatory.
What are the conditions for a valid Islamic marriage?
For a valid Islamic marriage (nikah), the following are required: offer and acceptance (ijab and qabul), the presence of a guardian (wali) for the bride, at least two Muslim witnesses, and a mahr (dowry) paid or promised to the bride. The marriage contract should be publicly announced. Marriage to certain categories of women is permanently or temporarily prohibited.
Comparative School Breakdown
A woman can contract her own marriage without a wali if she is of sound mind and mature age.
The wali is a pillar of the marriage contract — the marriage is invalid without him.
The wali is required. A virgin cannot be married without her wali's consent.
The wali is required. Agrees broadly with the Shafi'i position.
What foods and drinks are forbidden (haram) in Islam?
Forbidden foods include pork and its by-products, blood, animals that died without being properly slaughtered (mayta), animals slaughtered in the name of other than Allah, carnivorous animals with fangs, birds of prey, and intoxicants (alcohol). Halal meat requires the animal to be slaughtered by a Muslim, Christian, or Jew while pronouncing the name of Allah.
Comparative School Breakdown
Considers all aquatic animals except fish to be impermissible. Insects are not permissible.
All sea creatures are permissible (including shrimp, lobster). Considers most insects impermissible.
All sea creatures are permissible. Locusts are permissible.
Generally permits all sea creatures. Agrees locusts are permitted.
Is intention required for acts of worship?
Intention (niyyah) is a prerequisite for all acts of worship in Islam. 'Actions are judged by intentions' (Hadith). The intention must be in the heart — speaking it aloud is a matter of scholarly difference. The intention distinguishes acts of worship from habit (e.g., fasting as an act of worship vs. simply not eating).
Comparative School Breakdown
Verbal intention is recommended (mustahabb) for prayer and Hajj. For fasting, the intention must be made before Fajr.
Verbal intention is an innovation (bid'ah) — the intention is in the heart alone.
Verbal intention is recommended (mustahabb) to help align the heart and tongue.
Verbal intention is not recommended. The intention is strictly in the heart.
Is Friday prayer (Jumu'ah) obligatory?
Friday prayer (Salat al-Jumu'ah) is a collective obligation (fard ayn) on every adult free Muslim male who is resident (not travelling). It replaces the Dhuhr prayer on Fridays. It consists of two rakahs and is preceded by two khutbahs (sermons). Missing three consecutive Fridays without a valid excuse is described in hadith as a cause of the heart being sealed.
Comparative School Breakdown
Requires a minimum number of people (varies: 3 to 40 according to different opinions). Women are exempt but may attend.
Women are generally exempt. Requires a town or settlement for validity.
Requires a minimum of 40 permanent residents. Travellers are exempt.
Requires 40 free adult male residents. Travellers and women are exempt.
Is bank interest (riba) forbidden in Islam?
Riba (usury/interest) is strictly prohibited in Islam. The Quran warns that those who deal in riba are in a state of war with Allah and His Messenger. This includes all forms of predetermined interest on loans. Islamic finance alternatives include murabaha (cost-plus sale), musharakah (partnership), and sukuk (Islamic bonds). All four schools agree on the prohibition of riba.
Comparative School Breakdown
Riba applies to six items mentioned in hadith: gold, silver, wheat, barley, dates, salt. Extends by analogy to all items sold by weight or measure.
Extends prohibition to all edibles and monetary items. Specifically addresses riba in currency exchange.
Agrees riba applies to gold, silver, and all edible items sold by weight or volume.
Broadly prohibits riba. Considers it one of the major sins.
What is the ruling on making up missed prayers (qada), and how should they be performed?
Making up missed prayers is obligatory (wajib) for all Muslims. The missed prayers should be performed in their original order when possible, with the same number of rakats as the original prayer. There is no expiation (kaffarah) required beyond performing the qada prayer itself, though repentance is spiritually recommended. The qada prayer is performed with the same conditions as the original prayer.
Comparative School Breakdown
Hanafi school emphasizes that qada prayers must be performed in order (tartib), and if many prayers are missed, one should begin with the oldest. The intention should specify which prayer is being made up.
Maliki school permits more flexibility in the order of qada prayers and allows performing them without strict adherence to the original sequence, especially if a large number are missed.
Shafi'i school requires tartib (order) in making up prayers and discourages delaying qada prayers unnecessarily. Intention must clearly specify which prayer is being performed.
Hanbali school obligates qada in order and emphasizes the seriousness of missed prayers, requiring sincere repentance along with making them up.
Is Witr prayer obligatory, and what is the correct time to perform it?
Witr prayer is highly recommended (mustahabb) in all schools, though some scholars classify it as wajib. It should be performed after Isha prayer and before Fajr, with three rakats being the most common form. The last rakat includes qunut (supplication) before bowing. Witr can be prayed as late as the last third of the night.
Comparative School Breakdown
Hanafi school considers Witr wajib (obligatory) and emphasizes performing it with three rakats. It should not be abandoned, and if missed, must be made up during the day.
Maliki school treats Witr as strongly recommended (mustahabb) but not obligatory, and allows flexibility in the number of rakats, though three is preferred.
Shafi'i school deems Witr mustahabb and recommends performing it with full dedication. The qunut supplication is considered sunna and should be included in the last rakat.
Hanbali school regards Witr as wajib and emphasizes its importance. It should be performed before sleep or in the last third of the night.
What is the status of the Sunnah prayers (rawatib), and are they obligatory or recommended?
The Sunnah prayers (rawatib) are highly recommended (mustahabb) but not obligatory. They consist of 12 rakats distributed around the five daily prayers: two before Fajr, four before Zuhr, two after Zuhr, two after Maghrib, and two after Isha. Performing them brings great reward and was consistently practiced by the Prophet Muhammad.
Comparative School Breakdown
Hanafi school strongly emphasizes the rawatib and considers them part of the perfection of the prayer. Abandoning them without excuse is disliked (makruh).
Maliki school recommends the rawatib but allows more flexibility, particularly for those with legitimate excuses such as work or travel.
Shafi'i school emphasizes the importance of the rawatib and their consistency in the Prophet's practice, making them highly recommended.
Hanbali school strongly encourages the rawatib as they were a consistent practice of the Prophet and are part of completing the prayer.
How should a sick person pray if they cannot stand or maintain the upright position?
A sick person should pray according to their physical ability: standing if possible, sitting if unable to stand, and lying on the side or back if unable to sit. The prayer remains valid as long as the person intends the direction of the Qibla and performs the basic movements of bowing and prostration as much as possible. The obligation to pray is not lifted due to illness.
Comparative School Breakdown
Hanafi school permits prayer while sitting and allows modifications to bowing and prostration movements, though the basic structure should be maintained as much as possible.
Maliki school is flexible regarding the sick person's prayer and allows significant modifications, including nodding for prostration if unable to bow and prostrate fully.
Shafi'i school requires the sick person to perform the movements according to their ability, with bowing lower than standing but not necessarily full prostration if impossible.
Hanbali school permits prayer in any position the sick person can manage, from sitting to lying down, with movements proportionate to their physical condition.
What is the ruling and reward for praying in congregation compared to praying alone?
Congregational prayer is highly recommended and brings significantly greater reward than praying alone—estimates range from 25 to 27 times more reward. While not obligatory for women and most men except Friday prayer, congregation strengthens community bonds and is spiritually emphasized. Praying behind an imam in congregation is preferred and brings communal blessings.
Comparative School Breakdown
Hanafi school strongly encourages congregational prayer for men and considers it mustahabb. The multiplied reward is emphasized, though technically it is not wajib except for Jumu'ah.
Maliki school recommends congregation and emphasizes its spiritual benefits but does not consider it wajib except for Friday prayer.
Shafi'i school strongly advocates for congregational prayer, especially in mosques, and highlights the significant reward increase and community unity it fosters.
Hanbali school considers congregation highly recommended and emphasizes that abandoning it repeatedly without excuse is disliked.
Is it permissible to pray while wearing shoes, and what are the conditions?
It is permissible to pray while wearing shoes if they are clean and free from impurities. The Prophet Muhammad wore shoes during prayer, and several hadith support this practice. However, shoes must not contain najasah (impurity), and it is preferable to remove them when praying in a mosque or clean space as a sign of respect and humility.
Comparative School Breakdown
Hanafi school permits praying in clean shoes and considers it permissible based on the Prophet's practice, though removing them in mosques is preferred.
Maliki school allows prayer in clean shoes but emphasizes the preference for removing them as a sign of respect in sacred spaces.
Shafi'i school permits praying with shoes if clean and considers this based on authentic hadith evidence from the Prophet's practice.
Hanbali school permits and even encourages praying in shoes as a Sunna of the Prophet, provided the shoes are ritually clean.
What should a person do if they realize they have najasah (impurity) on their clothing during prayer?
If a person realizes during prayer that they have najasah on their clothing, the prayer is invalid and must be repeated after removing the impure item or changing clothes. However, if the najasah is very small (less than the size of a dirham), the prayer may remain valid depending on the madhab. Prevention through checking clothes before prayer is strongly encouraged.
Comparative School Breakdown
Hanafi school invalidates prayer if najasah is present on clothing, regardless of size, requiring the prayer to be repeated after purification.
Maliki school permits prayer if najasah is minor or small, particularly for minor impurities, and only requires repetition for major or obvious impurities.
Shafi'i school requires the removal of all najasah before prayer, with strict standards regarding purity of clothing.
Hanbali school invalidates prayer with najasah on clothing and requires repetition after removing the impure item.
What is the sutrah (barrier), and how important is it to have one during prayer?
The sutrah is a barrier placed in front of the praying person to prevent others from passing in front during prayer. It is highly recommended (mustahabb) to have a sutrah, preferably about a meter high, such as a stick, wall, or prayer stand. The sutrah serves to protect the prayer and is Sunnah, though prayer without one remains valid. It also defines a protected prayer space.
Comparative School Breakdown
Hanafi school considers the sutrah mustahabb and recommends having one that is at least as high as a walking stick. Its absence does not invalidate prayer.
Maliki school recommends the sutrah but is more lenient regarding its necessity and allows prayer without it in most circumstances.
Shafi'i school emphasizes the importance of the sutrah as Sunnah and recommends having one when possible.
Hanbali school strongly recommends the sutrah and considers it part of the Sunnah of prayer, though not obligatory.
What are the different methods of calculating prayer times, and which is most reliable?
Prayer times are calculated based on the sun's position: Fajr (before sunrise), Zuhr (when sun passes meridian), Asr (afternoon shadow), Maghrib (at sunset), and Isha (after twilight disappears). Modern calculation methods include shadow length ratios, astronomical tables, and software. The most widely accepted is the angle-based method, with different angles used by various regions and organizations.
Comparative School Breakdown
Hanafi school traditionally uses specific shadow length calculations for Asr and emphasizes the importance of accurate astronomical observation.
Maliki school allows various calculation methods and is flexible regarding minor differences in timing.
Shafi'i school uses specific angle measurements for prayer time calculations, particularly for Fajr and Isha based on twilight visibility.
Hanbali school employs astronomical methods and shadow calculations, with emphasis on observable celestial indicators when possible.
Is it permissible to pray in a place where there are images or pictures on the walls?
Praying in a place with images is disliked (makruh) according to most scholars, as images can distract from the focus (khushu) required in prayer. However, the prayer remains valid. It is preferable to pray away from images or to cover them if possible. The prohibition is stronger for three-dimensional statues and animate creature images.
Comparative School Breakdown
Hanafi school considers prayer in a place with images makruh, especially if the images are directly in front of the praying person or depict animate creatures.
Maliki school dislikes praying with images present but is lenient if they cannot be avoided, particularly for small or distant images.
Shafi'i school emphasizes that images distract from khushu and recommends avoiding them, though prayer remains valid if they are unavoidable.
Hanbali school strongly discourages praying where images are visible and recommends covering or avoiding such places when possible.
Is zakat obligatory on gold and silver ornaments worn by women for personal adornment?
The majority of Islamic scholars agree that zakat is due on gold and silver jewelry that is hoarded or not regularly worn, as it constitutes wealth. However, there is scholarly difference regarding jewelry in active use for personal adornment, with some schools exempting it based on the principle of necessity and wear.
Comparative School Breakdown
Zakat is due on all gold and silver exceeding the nisab threshold, regardless of whether it is worn or hoarded, as the form does not remove the obligation of zakat on precious metals.
Zakat is obligatory on gold and silver jewelry, with no exemption for items in use, as the precious metal itself is the basis for the obligation.
Zakat is due on gold and silver jewelry only if it is hoarded and not worn regularly; jewelry in active use by women may be exempted as it serves a purpose beyond mere wealth storage.
Zakat is obligatory on all gold and silver regardless of form or use, following the strict interpretation that precious metals are always subject to zakat.
How should zakat be calculated on goods held in stock for business purposes?
Zakat on business inventory is calculated based on the market value of unsold goods at the end of the zakat year. The merchant must include the current market value of all inventory in their zakat calculation, treating it as part of their total wealth subject to the 2.5% zakat rate.
Comparative School Breakdown
Zakat on inventory is calculated at fair market value as of the zakat year end, and is obligatory on all merchants holding goods for sale, regardless of turnover rate.
Inventory zakat is assessed at market value, with consideration for the cost of goods and potential profit; the merchant values goods at their selling price for zakat purposes.
Zakat on inventory is due at market value on the zakat anniversary, calculated similarly to cash holdings as part of total wealth.
Merchants must pay zakat on inventory at fair market value as determined on the zakat due date, with no special exemptions for slow-moving goods.
What is the amount and nature of Sadaqah al-Fitr that must be paid before Eid al-Fitr prayer?
Sadaqah al-Fitr is a mandatory charity paid by each Muslim household before Eid al-Fitr prayer, intended to purify the fasting person and provide for the needy. The amount is typically one sa' (approximately 2.5-3 kg) of staple food per person, or its monetary equivalent, though schools differ on the exact quantity and substance.
Comparative School Breakdown
One sa' of wheat, barley, dates, or raisins per person is obligatory; the monetary value is calculated based on local grain prices, not market food prices.
One sa' of the local staple food is required per person; this can be any grain or food commonly eaten in the region, paid before Eid prayer.
One sa' of food grains, dates, or raisins is mandatory per household member; the exact amount may vary based on what is commonly used as sustenance.
One sa' of the most common food of the people is obligatory per person, with flexibility in what constitutes the staple food of the community.
What are the Islamic requirements and conditions for giving and receiving qard hasan (virtuous loan)?
Qard hasan is a recommended Islamic financial practice involving interest-free lending where the borrower returns only the principal amount lent. It is based on mutual goodwill and compassion, with the lender receiving reward from Allah rather than financial gain. Both lender and borrower must have clear intention, and the loan terms should be clearly documented to prevent disputes.
Comparative School Breakdown
Qard hasan is a transaction of trust; if no specific time is set for repayment, the lender cannot demand it immediately but should allow reasonable time; both parties must be competent adults.
The loan should be documented in writing to establish proof; the lender may request repayment at any reasonable time, though immediate demand without agreement is disliked.
Qard hasan requires clear agreement on the amount and is a binding contract; the borrower must repay the exact amount borrowed without any additional compensation.
The loan should have clear terms agreed upon by both parties; qard hasan is valid even without witnesses, but written documentation is recommended for clarity.
What are the valid conditions and profit distribution rules in mudharabah (Islamic profit-sharing venture)?
Mudharabah is a legitimate Islamic partnership where one party (capital provider) supplies funds and another (worker/manager) provides labor and expertise, with profits distributed according to an agreed ratio. The contract must specify the profit-sharing percentage, and losses are borne by the capital provider while the worker loses their effort.
Comparative School Breakdown
The mudharabah contract requires clear specification of the profit ratio; the capital provider bears all losses while the worker is not responsible for loss unless there is negligence or breach of contract.
Both parties should agree on specific profit percentages; if not specified, profits are divided equally; the contract is binding once terms are accepted.
The profit-sharing ratio must be explicitly stated at contract formation; undefined ratios invalidate the contract, and the worker bears no liability for capital losses without fault.
Clear agreement on profit division is essential; the mudharabah requires specification of the worker's share before the venture begins, and disputes are resolved by the agreement terms.
Is it permissible to sell goods or commodities that the seller does not yet possess or have delivered?
Islamic jurisprudence generally prohibits selling goods before taking possession of them, as this involves gharar (excessive uncertainty) and risk of non-delivery. However, there are specific exceptions for certain contracts like salam (pre-ordered goods) where the seller agrees to deliver specific goods at a future date for immediate payment.
Comparative School Breakdown
Selling before possession is generally prohibited; however, salam contracts are permissible where the buyer pays for goods to be delivered later with specific terms agreed.
The seller must have possessed goods before sale; an exception is made for salam contracts involving known commodities with delivery timelines clearly specified.
Taking possession before sale is a condition for validity in most cases; salam and istisna' (commissioned production) are exceptions where payment precedes delivery.
Direct possession is required for most sales; salam is permitted for foodstuffs and necessities with clear specifications, preventing the sale of unknown goods.
Is conventional insurance permissible in Islam, and what is the ruling on Islamic insurance (Takaful)?
Conventional insurance is considered impermissible by most Islamic scholars due to riba (interest), gharar (excessive uncertainty), and maysir (gambling) elements. Islamic insurance (Takaful) is the approved alternative, operating on the principle of mutual cooperation where participants share risks and premiums collectively without interest-based returns.
Comparative School Breakdown
Conventional insurance involves prohibited riba and gharar; Takaful on mutual cooperation basis is acceptable if structured without interest and unclear terms.
Insurance contracts are viewed as impermissible due to risk transfer and uncertainty; Islamic cooperative insurance models following mutual benefit principles are preferable.
Conventional insurance is prohibited due to maysir and gharar; Takaful structured as a cooperative pooling arrangement without interest is considered permissible.
Insurance in conventional form is impermissible; Islamic Takaful based on genuine mutual cooperation and shared responsibility is the accepted alternative.
Is it permissible to trade, hold, or invest in cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin according to Islamic law?
Islamic scholars have differing views on cryptocurrency legality. Most contemporary scholars recognize Bitcoin and similar cryptocurrencies as having some utility and value, but raise concerns about extreme volatility, lack of intrinsic value backing, gambling-like speculation, and potential use in illicit activities. The consensus leans toward caution with permissibility conditional on halal use and avoiding excessive speculation.
Comparative School Breakdown
Cryptocurrencies may be treated as commodities if they have recognized utility and value; trading them is permissible if not engaged in excessive speculation or gambling-like behavior.
The status depends on actual use and utility; if cryptocurrency serves real economic purposes without speculation, it may be permissible as a medium of exchange.
Cryptocurrencies lack intrinsic value and are subject to extreme volatility, raising concerns about maysir; trading them is discouraged unless for legitimate utility purposes.
Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies present excessive uncertainty and risk of maysir through speculation; most contemporary Hanbali scholars view them with caution or prohibition.
Is it permissible for a Muslim to work in a conventional bank involved in riba-based transactions?
The majority of Islamic scholars prohibit working in conventional banking institutions because such employment directly facilitates riba (interest), which is explicitly forbidden in Islam. However, some scholars permit limited roles that do not directly involve interest transactions, with strong preference for Islamic banking employment.
Comparative School Breakdown
Working in banks dealing with riba is impermissible as it constitutes assisting in forbidden transactions; only administrative roles with no involvement in interest dealings may be considered with reluctance.
Employment in conventional banks is generally prohibited; the prohibition extends to all positions that support the riba-based system, even indirectly.
Bank employment involving riba is haram; however, some scholars permit positions that are entirely separate from interest transactions, though this is a minority view.
Working in banks based on riba is forbidden; even administrative positions supporting the system are discouraged as they facilitate prohibited activity.
Under what conditions is investing in the stock market considered halal in Islamic finance?
Stock market investing is permissible in Islam when focused on companies engaged in halal (permissible) business activities and avoiding those with significant haram (forbidden) involvement. Investors must carefully screen companies to ensure they avoid interest-based financing, prohibited products/services, and excessive debt, while dividends must derive from legitimate business profits.
Comparative School Breakdown
Stock investment is permissible in halal companies; investors should avoid companies with significant riba involvement or haram products, though minor dealings may be tolerated.
Investment in stock markets is acceptable if focused on companies with permissible activities; strict screening is required to eliminate those involved in interest, alcohol, or prohibited services.
Stocks are permissible if the underlying company operates in halal sectors; investors must verify that the company does not rely on riba for operations or major financing.
Stock market investment is acceptable for companies in halal industries; strict avoidance of interest-bearing companies and prohibited business sectors is required.
Can impure water (najis) be used for wudu or ghusl?
Impure water (najis) cannot be used for purification as it does not remove impurity but rather compounds it. All four madhabs agree that only pure water (tahir or mutahhar) is valid for ablution and ritual bathing. Using najis water renders the purification invalid.
Comparative School Breakdown
Impure water is absolutely forbidden for wudu and ghusl; it invalidates both. Only tahir (intrinsically pure) or mutahhar (purified) water is acceptable.
Najis water cannot be used for purification under any circumstance, even if mixed with pure water unless the water returns to the state of purity.
Impure water invalidates purification entirely. A person must use water that is pure in itself and has not been affected by impurity.
Najis water is completely forbidden for ablution or bathing. The water must be pure and free from all forms of impurity to be valid.
What is the difference between tahir (intrinsically pure) water and mutahhar (purified) water?
Tahir water is pure by its nature and has never been affected by impurity, making it the most preferred for purification. Mutahhar water is water that was previously affected by minor impurity but has been restored to purity through dilution or change. Both are valid for wudu and ghusl, though tahir is superior.
Comparative School Breakdown
Tahir water is pristine and preferred; mutahhar water (like rainwater that touched najasah then was diluted) is permissible if it has returned to its natural state of purity.
Both tahir and mutahhar water are acceptable for purification, but tahir is more virtuous and preferred when available.
Tahir water is the ideal standard for purification; mutahhar water is valid if the impurity has been removed and the water's properties have changed back to normalcy.
Tahir water is most praiseworthy for purification; mutahhar water is permissible as long as the impurity has been completely removed and the water is restored.
When is ghusl (ritual bath) obligatory, and what are the conditions that necessitate it?
Ghusl is obligatory after sexual intercourse, ejaculation of semen (whether during intercourse or otherwise), completion of menstruation, and completion of postpartum bleeding. All four madhabs agree on these main occasions. Ghusl requires complete washing of the entire body with intention.
Comparative School Breakdown
Ghusl is obligatory for sexual intercourse (with or without ejaculation), ejaculation of semen due to arousal or wet dreams, end of menstruation, and end of postpartum bleeding.
Ghusl becomes obligatory upon sexual intercourse, ejaculation of semen, completion of menstruation, and completion of postpartum bleeding (nifas).
Ghusl is obligatory when semen is emitted due to desire or wetness during sleep, after sexual intercourse, at the end of menstruation, and at the end of postpartum bleeding.
Ghusl is obligatory for sexual intercourse, semen emission regardless of cause, end of menses, end of nifas, and death (performed by others). Death of a Muslim requires ghusl before burial.
When is tayammum (dry ablution) permitted as an alternative to wudu?
Tayammum is permitted when water is unavailable, when using water would cause harm to oneself, or when one cannot reach water without excessive difficulty. It involves striking clean earth with both hands and wiping the face and hands. All madhabs agree on its permissibility under these conditions as a substitute for wudu.
Comparative School Breakdown
Tayammum is valid when water is unavailable, inaccessible, or when using it would cause physical harm. It requires intention and must be performed with clean earth or dust.
Tayammum is permitted when water is absent, when obtaining it would cause hardship, or when a person fears harm from using water due to illness or extreme cold.
Tayammum is valid for those without water access and also for those unable to use water due to fear of harm from cold, illness, or wounds. The person must intend the purification.
Tayammum is permissible when water cannot be found, when one cannot reach water due to distance or fear, or when water use would harm the person's health or condition.
Is wiping over khuffs (leather socks) during ablution valid, and for how long?
Wiping over khuffs (waterproof leather socks/boots) is valid and permitted in Islam as an ease from the Prophet Muhammad's practice. The duration of wiping validity is one day and night for a non-traveler, and three days and nights for a traveler. The wiper must have put them on while in a state of purity.
Comparative School Breakdown
Wiping over khuffs is valid for one day and night from the time of first wiping. A traveler may wipe for three days and nights. The khuffs must have been worn after achieving wudu.
Wiping over khuffs is permitted and valid; the duration is one full day and night for the resident and three days and nights for the traveler, beginning from the first wiping.
Wiping over khuffs is allowed for one day and night for those at home and three days and nights while traveling. The person must have entered the state of purity before donning the khuffs.
Wiping over khuffs is valid for one day and night for the resident and three days and nights for the traveler, counting from the first wiping performed, provided the khuffs were put on after achieving ritual purity.
What is the ruling on wiping over bandages or medical wrappings (jabira) during ablution?
Wiping over bandages and medical wrappings (jabira) covering wounds or injuries is permitted when washing that area would cause harm or prevent healing. If the bandage can be removed without harm, it should be removed and the area washed. If removal would cause pain or complications, wiping over the bandage is sufficient.
Comparative School Breakdown
If a wound is covered with a bandage that cannot be removed without harm, wiping over it in ablution is sufficient. If it can be removed without detriment, the area must be washed and the bandage replaced.
Wiping over bandages is permissible when removing them would harm the healing wound. However, if the bandage can be safely removed, the underlying area should be washed.
Wiping over bandages (jabira) is valid when removal would cause harm to a wound or illness. The wiping must reach the bandage directly, and if the wound is not covered, the affected area should be washed.
When an injury is bandaged and removal would cause harm, wiping over the bandage in wudu is sufficient and valid. If the bandage cannot be safely removed, wiping replaces washing that area.
How should najasah (impurity) be removed from clothing, and is prayer affected?
Najasah must be removed from clothing before prayer, as prayer with impurity is invalid. Light impurity (najasah hafifah) requires washing the affected area; heavy impurity (najasah ghalizah) also requires washing or scrubbing. If a person is unaware of the impurity during prayer, the prayer is valid, but it must be repeated once the impurity is discovered.
Comparative School Breakdown
Najasah must be removed by washing the affected area of clothing. Prayer performed while knowingly carrying najasah is invalid. If unaware, the prayer is valid but should be repeated after cleaning.
Light impurity requires washing the area; heavy impurity requires thorough washing or cleaning with water and possibly scrubbing. Prayer is invalid if performed with awareness of impurity.
Najasah must be completely removed from clothing through washing. Prayer with known impurity on one's clothing is invalid and must be repeated after purification.
All types of najasah must be removed from clothing by washing the contaminated area before prayer. Prayer with known impurity is invalid, though if unknowingly performed, it does not require repetition.
What is the Islamic ruling on dog saliva and its effect on purification?
According to the majority of Islamic scholars, dog saliva is considered najasah (impurity). If it comes into contact with a person's body, clothing, or objects, those items must be washed seven times, with the first or one of the washings involving earth/soil. This ruling is based on authentic hadith and is followed by all four madhabs with slight variations.
Comparative School Breakdown
Dog saliva is najasah; if it touches a person or object, the affected area must be washed seven times with water, one of which should include washing with earth or soil.
Contact with dog saliva requires washing seven times, with one washing involving earth. Some Maliki scholars permit using sand or dust as the cleansing agent in one washing.
Dog saliva is impure and requires washing the contaminated area seven times, with one washing involving earth or soil to ensure complete purification.
Dog saliva is najasah and requires seven washings of the contaminated area, with the first or one of the washings involving earth. This is the strict application of the hadith.
Do wet dreams require ghusl, and what is the ruling if no semen is discharged?
If a wet dream results in semen emission, ghusl is obligatory. If a person experiences a wet dream but no semen is discharged, only wudu is required, not ghusl. The presence of semen is the determining factor across all four madhabs. Some scholars distinguish between wet dreams with certainty of semen discharge versus uncertainty.
Comparative School Breakdown
If semen is discharged during a wet dream, ghusl is obligatory. If only fluid is released without semen, or if there is doubt about whether semen was discharged, only wudu is needed.
Ghusl is required only if semen is actually discharged during the wet dream. If no semen is released, even if other fluids appear, wudu alone is sufficient.
If semen is emitted during a wet dream, ghusl becomes obligatory. If the person is uncertain whether semen was discharged, the more cautious position is to perform ghusl.
Ghusl is obligatory upon semen emission from a wet dream. If no semen is released, wudu is sufficient. The person should examine themselves to determine if semen was actually discharged.
What are the Islamic rulings on menstruation regarding prayer, fasting, and ghusl?
During menstruation, a woman must not pray or fast. Menstrual blood is ritually impure, and prayer and fasting are invalid during this period. Once menstruation ends, ghusl becomes obligatory before resuming prayer. The missed fasts must be made up after Ramadan, but missed prayers do not need to be made up. All four madhabs agree on these fundamental rulings.
Comparative School Breakdown
Prayer and fasting are forbidden during menstruation; both are invalid if performed. Ghusl is obligatory upon the end of menstruation before prayer can resume. Missed fasts must be made up; missed prayers are not made up.
A menstruating woman cannot pray or fast; her prayer and fasting are null. Upon cessation of menstruation, ghusl is required before prayer. Fasts are made up; prayers are not.
Prayer and fasting are prohibited during menstruation and are invalid if performed. Ghusl is obligatory at the end of menses. Fasts must be made up; prayers need not be repeated.
Menstruating women are prohibited from prayer and fasting; both are invalid during menstruation. Ghusl is obligatory when menses cease. Missed fasts are made up; missed prayers are not made up.